A Legal Analysis of the Point in Time for Determining Property Exempt from Execution: A Comparative Perspective with Reference to the Common Law

Document Type : Academicm and Research

Author

Associate Professor, Department of Law, Faculty of Administrative Sciences and Economics, University of Isfahan, Iran.

Abstract

The point in time at which property exempt from execution (mustathnayāt-i dayn) falls to be determined is a matter that has been largely overlooked in legal scholarship, notwithstanding its critical importance for the coherent application of the Iranian Civil Judgment Enforcement Act, the Law on the Enforcement of Financial Judgments, and the bankruptcy provisions of the Commercial Code and the Law on the Administration of Bankruptcy Proceedings. This article undertakes a systematic legal analysis of this temporal criterion, designated as the moment of enforcement, and examines its doctrinal foundations, its practical implications, and its interaction with the related concepts of priority rights and insolvency. The study identifies the moment of issuance of the enforcement writ as the operative point in time for ordinary judgment debtors, and the moment of issuance of the bankruptcy judgment at first instance for bankrupts. It argues that the determination of this moment plays a decisive role in resolving a range of legal ambiguities, including the debtor's capacity to acquire or augment exempt property after the commencement of enforcement proceedings, the classification of exempt property into fixed and ongoing categories, and the legal consequences of deliberately incurring debt for the purpose of acquiring assets that would subsequently qualify as exempt from execution. The analysis further examines the inapplicability of this temporal criterion to legal persons and deceased natural persons, the manner in which the moment of enforcement governs the eligibility of dependants for exemption, and the complex interaction between the rules governing exempt property and the system of priority rights among creditors. Drawing upon a comparative perspective with reference to the common law, the article identifies both shared principles and notable divergences, including the absence in Iranian law of certain exemptions recognised in common law jurisdictions, such as life insurance policies and the wages of police and fire department officers, and the corresponding absence in the common law of certain Iranian exemptions, such as the cost of funeral clothing and a separate exemption for books and research tools. The study concludes that the systematic recognition and application of the moment of enforcement is indispensable for the coherent operation of the law of execution and for the fair balancing of the competing interests of judgment creditors and debtors.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

ابوعطا، محمد (1389). «حق ممتاز دریایی؛ طلب یا وثیقه طلب.»، فصلنامه حقوق، دوره 4، شماره 3.
اسکینی، ربیعا (1375). ورشکستگی و تصفیه امور ورشکسته، تهران: سمت.
انوریپور، محسن (1353). ورشکستگی در حقوق ایران، تهران: نشر بابک.
آل‌شیخ، محمد (1384). «حقوق و تعهدات بیمه‌گذار.»، فصلنامه صنعت بیمه، دوره 20، شماره 3.
تهرانی، حسن ستوده (1350). حقوق تجارت، جلد 4. تهران: انتشارات دهخدا.
حسنی، حسن (1380). حقوق تجارت، تهران: میزان.
حسینی، محمدرضا (1383). قانون اجرای احکام مدنی در رویه قضایی، تهران: نگاه بینه.
راستین، منصور (1351). حقوق بازرگانی، تهران: انتشارات دانشگاه تهران.
روشن، محمد و حسن محمدی (1392). «تأثیر ورشکستگی و اعسار زوج بر مطالبات زوجه»، فصلنامه خانواده پژوهی، دوره ۹، شماره ۳۳.
ساعتچی، علی و فاطمه منتظر ابدی (1402). «مطالعه تطبیقی وضعیت حقوقی قراردادهای تاجر ورشکسته بعد از صدور حکم ورشکستگی»، پژوهش تطبیقی حقوق اسلام و غرب، دوره 10، شماره 4.
شمس، عبدالله (1385). آیین دادرسی مدنی، جلد 3. تهران: انتشارات دراک.
صدرزاده افشار، محسن (1379). آیین دادرسی مدنی و بازرگانی، تهران: ماجد.
صفیان، سعید (1387). «بحثی پیرامون حق تقدم دولت در وصول مطالبات مالیاتی» ، مجله تخصصی الهیات و حقوق، شماره 28 .
صقری، محمد (1376). حقوق بازرگانی، ورشکستگی، نظری و عملی، تهران: شرکت سهامی انتشار.
عرفانی، محمود (1366). حقوق تجارت، جلد 3. تهران: انتشارات جهاد دانشگاهی.
کاتبی، حسینقلی (1375). حقوق تجارت، تهران: گنج دانش.
کریمی، عباس (1386). آیین دادرسی مدنی، تهران: مجمع علمی و فرهنگی مجد.
محسنی، حسن (1391). «اجرای مؤثر رأی مدنی (مفهوم، راهکارها و موانع)»، فصلنامه حقوق، دوره 42، شماره ۴.
محمدزاده، مسلم (1394). «تن آدمی شریف است به جان آدمیت؟! پرتوهایی از کرامت انسانی در حقوق خصوصی»، فصلنامه مطالعات حقوق خصوصی، دوره 45، شماره 2.
مدنی، جلال‌الدین (1357). آیین دادرسی مدنی، جلد 2. تهران: انتشارات دانشگاه ملی ایران.
مدنی، جلال‌الدین (1369). آیین دادرسی مدنی – اجرای احکام، تهران: گنج دانش.
مهاجری، علی (1380). شرح قانون آیین دادرسی مدنی دادگاه‌های عمومی و انقلاب، جلد ۱ و 3. تهران: گنج دانش.
مهاجری، علی (1383). شرح جامع قانون اجرای احکام مدنی، جلد 1 و ۲، تهران: انتشارات فکرسازان.
References
Brown, J. J. (2022). Judgment enforcement. Wolters Kluwer.
Cotter, M. P. (1980). The failure of the Virginia exemption plan. William & Mary Law Review, 21(3), 851–880.
Council of Europe. (1998). The execution of court decisions in civil cases. Council of Europe Publishing.
Greenfield, M. M. (1975). A constitutional limitation on the enforcement of judgments: Due process and exemptions. Washington University Law Review, (4), 877–932.
Herzog, P. E., & Weser, M. (1967). Civil procedure in France. Martinus Nijhoff.
Hoffman, D., Phillipson, G., & Young, A. L. (2011). Introduction. In D. Hoffman (Ed.), The impact of the UK Human Rights Act on private law (pp. 1–16). Cambridge University Press.
Laughlin, P., & Gerlis, S. (2012). Civil procedure. Cavendish Publishing.
Levine, D. I., & Shapell, R. J. (2012). Quick review of California civil procedure. West.
Manghutay, A. G. (2007). Scrutinizing the legal aspects of polygamy in Iran. LawAsia Journal, 239–249.
Nadler, M. J. (1955). Exemptions. Ohio State Law Journal, 16, 63–80.
O'Neill, C. (2021). Everybody's guide to small claims court in California. Bang Printing.
Saclaw. (2014). Exemptions from the enforcement of judgments. Sacramento County Public Law Library.
Sinha, S. (2015). Code of civil procedure of California: U.S. law series. AudioBook Publishing.
Walker, J. C. (2006). Wyoming's statutory exemption on wage garnishment: Should it include deposited wages? Wyoming Law Review, 6(1), 52–86.
 
In Persian
Abu Ata, M. (2010). Maritime lien: A claim or security for a claim? Journal of Law, 4(3). [In Persian]
Eskini, R. (1996). Bankruptcy and the administration of bankrupt estates. Tehran: SAMT Publications. [In Persian]
Anvaripour, M. (1974). Bankruptcy in Iranian law. Tehran: Babak Publications. [In Persian]
Al-Sheikh, M. (2005). Rights and obligations of the insured. Insurance Industry Quarterly, 20(3). [In Persian]
Sotoudeh Tehrani, H. (1971). Commercial law (Vol. 4). Tehran: Dehkhoda Publications. [In Persian]
Hasani, H. (2001). Commercial law. Tehran: Mizan Publications. [In Persian]
Hosseini, M. R. (2004). The Civil Judgment Enforcement Act in judicial practice. Tehran: Negah Bineh Publications. [In Persian]
Rastin, M. (1972). Commercial law. Tehran: University of Tehran Press. [In Persian]
Roshan, M., & Mohammadi, H. (2013). The effect of bankruptcy and insolvency of the husband on the wife's financial claims. Family Research Quarterly, 9(33). [In Persian]
Saatchi, A., & Montazer Abadi, F. (2024). A comparative study of the legal status of contracts concluded by a bankrupt merchant after the bankruptcy judgment. Comparative Research on Islamic and Western Law, 10(4). [In Persian]
Shams, A. (2006). Civil procedure (Vol. 3). Tehran: Darrak Publications. [In Persian]
Sadrzadeh Afshar, M. (2000). Civil and commercial procedure. Tehran: Majed Publications. [In Persian]
Safian, S. (2008). A discussion of the government's priority right in the collection of tax claims. Specialized Journal of Theology and Law, (28). [In Persian]
Soghari, M. (1997). Commercial law: Bankruptcy, theoretical and practical. Tehran: Enteshar Joint Stock Company. [In Persian]
Erfani, M. (1987). Commercial law (Vol. 3). Tehran: Academic Jihad Publications. [In Persian]
Katebi, H. (1996). Commercial law. Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh Publications. [In Persian]
Karimi, A. (2007). Civil procedure. Tehran: Majd Scientific and Cultural Association. [In Persian]
Mohseni, H. (2012). Effective enforcement of civil judgments: Concept, mechanisms, and obstacles. Journal of Law, 42(4). [In Persian]
Mohammadzadeh, M. (2015). Is the human being ennobled by humanity? Reflections on human dignity in private law. Journal of Private Law Studies, 45(2). [In Persian]
Madani, J. (1978). Civil procedure (Vol. 2). Tehran: National University of Iran Press. [In Persian]
Madani, J. (1990). Civil procedure: Enforcement of judgments. Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh Publications. [In Persian]
Mohajeri, A. (2001). Commentary on the Civil Procedure Code of the General and Revolutionary Courts (Vols. 1 & 3). Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh Publications. [In Persian]
Mohajeri, A. (2004). Comprehensive commentary on the Civil Judgment Enforcement Act (Vols. 1 & 2). Tehran: Fekrsazan Publications. [In Persian]
Send comment about this article
CAPTCHA Image

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics