Document Type : Academicm and Research

Author

Assistant Professor of Maragheh University Law Department.

10.22091/csiw.2024.10453.2509

Abstract

In 2004, religious clothing was banned in French schools with the justification of adherence to the principles of laicity. Since then, various laws, bills and guidelines regarding the restriction of religious clothing, focusing on Islamic hijab, have been put on the agenda. The present article evaluates the limitations of the hijab with a human rights approach using a descriptive-analytical method and using library resources. The findings of this article show that, firstly, for denying or limiting the rights of individuals, the criteria should be human rights documents and not the principles of laicity. Secondly; Laicity in its common and true meaning does not show such restrictions, but French politicians in the name and in the form of laicity present laws that are contrary to fundamental human rights, such as "the right to freedom of religious rites" and "the right to religious education of children". Thirdly, the dual approach of the French laws cannot be justified and it is not clear that the French legislator who doubts the decision-making power and eligibility of teenagers to choose religious clothing is based on the independence of the decision-making of teenagers for sexual consent at the age of 15 in the law on strengthening the protection of children against It has recognized sexual violence approved in 2021?

Keywords

Main Subjects

Arsheh, Gay (1385), Laicity, translated by Abdul Wahab Ahmadi, Tehran: Age Publishing House, pp. 7-17.
Ahmadi, Hamid; Salimi, proof. (1401). Ideological conflicts and institutionalization of laicité in modern France. Politics Quarterly, 52(1), 1-26.
Stuart Mill, John (2016). Treatise on freedom. Translated by Dr. Javad Sheikh al-Islami, 6th chapter. Tehran: Scientific and Cultural.
Rahai, Saeed (2009) Religious freedom from the perspective of international law with a view to the Islamic approach, first edition Qom: Mofid University.
Zahdian, Mohammad Hossein and Sadri Arhami, Mohammad. (2019). Investigating the place of hijab in human rights from the perspective of universalism and relativism. Women and Family Educational Cultural Quarterly, 15(52).
Zamani, Qasim; Hosseini Azad, Ali (2013) A reflection on the treatment of the European Court of Human Rights with Article 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights based on the case of Leila Shahin, article, Islamic Human Rights Studies 3(6).
Soodmandi, Abdul Majeed, Sharifi Tarzkouhi Hossein (2012) Scope of the right to freedom
of religion and belief in international human rights documents. Comparative Law Research, 16(4): 77-103.
Shamsi, Ahmadreza (2010). Europe's international legal obligations regarding the freedom of hijab. Foreign Policy, 25, 170-147
Fadaeli, Mustafa, Kerami, Musa, Asadi, Soraya. (2016). Supporting religious minorities in the Islamic legal system and the international human rights system. Comparative Research of Islamic and Western Laws, 4(1), 113-142.
Kianpour, Masoud and Yazdkhavast, Behjat (1385) Historical Sociology of Secularism: Sociological Investigation of the Law Prohibiting the Use of Religious Symbols in Public Schools in France, Women's Studies Quarterly, 4(3).
Gerji, Ali Akbar. (1387). Democracy and religious freedom in the context of laicity: a critique on the paradoxes of French laicity. Law and Politics, 10(25), 155-192.
Maggi, Amir and Makki, Shadi Sadat (2017). Manifestations of the right to freedom of religious expression in the practice of international human rights institutions. Tehran University Public Law Studies Quarterly (1) 48. 139-157.
Malekizadeh, Amir Hossein; Mousavi Far, Seyyed Hossein. (1401). An attitude on the margin of discretion doctrine in interpretation. Tehran University Public Law Studies Quarterly, 52(4).
Mousavi Mirklai, Seyyed Taha, Dehnavi, Mohammad and Mohammadzadeh, Savalan. (1402). The freedom of Muslim women's religious clothing from the point of view of international law, emphasizing the opinions of the European Court of Human Rights. Tehran University Public Law Studies Quarterly.
CAPTCHA Image